Skip to content

A non-government entity

Medicare Annual Enrollment is open until December 7. Compare 2027 plans now.

Bookmark this site for future free quotes & support!

GenieMedicare

Attained Age vs Issue Age Medigap: How Rates Rise

Understand how attained-age, issue-age, and community-rated Medigap policies price their premiums and what it means for your long-term retirement budget.

Genie Medicare Team Published 11 min read
Older woman budgeting for healthcare costs, comparing attained age vs issue age pricing

The short answer

Attained-age Medigap policies base your premium on your current age, meaning rates automatically increase as you get older. Issue-age policies base your premium on the age you were when you bought the plan, so rates do not increase just because you have a birthday.

Key takeaways

  • Attained-age policies start cheaper but automatically raise your rates as you get older.
  • Issue-age policies base your premium on your starting age, avoiding age-based increases.
  • Community-rated policies charge everyone in the same area the exact same monthly premium.
  • All Medigap policies, regardless of the rating method, will experience rate increases due to inflation.
  • Your state insurance department determines which pricing methods insurance companies are allowed to sell.
  • Switching policies later to find a better rate often requires passing medical underwriting.
  • Compare long-term costs, not just the starting premium, when choosing your Medigap policy.
In this article
  1. What Are Medigap Pricing Rating Methods?
  2. How Attained-Age Medigap Pricing Works
  3. How Issue-Age Medigap Pricing Works
  4. How Community-Rated Medigap Pricing Works
  5. Comparing Attained-Age vs Issue-Age Medigap Costs
  6. Why Medical Inflation Affects Every Medigap Policy
  7. How Your State Regulates Medigap Rating Systems
  8. Can You Switch Rating Methods Later?
  9. The Impact of MACRA on Closed Plans
  10. Which Rating Method Offers Better Long-Term Stability?
  11. How to Find the Rating Method on Your Policy
  12. How to Compare Medigap Rates in 30 Seconds

When you first sign up for Medicare, choosing a Medicare Supplement (Medigap) plan can feel overwhelming. Beyond picking a plan letter, you also have to understand how the insurance company calculates your monthly bill. The biggest decision for your long-term budget often comes down to understanding attained age vs issue age pricing.

These terms describe the "rating method" an insurance company uses to set your premium. If you only look at the starting price at age 65, you might be in for a shock when you turn 75 or 80. By learning how these three primary pricing methods—attained-age, issue-age, and community-rated—work, you can better anticipate your future costs and make a confident choice for your retirement.

What Are Medigap Pricing Rating Methods?

Medigap policies are sold by private insurance companies to help pay for the out-of-pocket costs that Original Medicare leaves behind. For example, a Medigap plan can help cover the Medicare Part A inpatient hospital deductible, which is $1,736 in 2026 and rising to $1,776 in 2027.

While the federal government standardizes the benefits of these plans (a Plan G from one company covers the exact same medical bills as a Plan G from another), the government does not standardize the prices. Insurance companies are allowed to set their own premiums using one of three pricing structures, also known as rating methods:

  • Attained-Age Rated: Your premium is based on your current age (the age you have "attained").
  • Issue-Age Rated: Your premium is based on the age you are when you first buy (are "issued") the policy.
  • Community-Rated: Your premium is the same as everyone else's in your area, regardless of age.

Understanding which method a policy uses is the secret to predicting how fast your monthly bills will climb as you navigate your seventies and eighties.

How Attained-Age Medigap Pricing Works

Attained-age pricing is the most common rating method used by Medigap insurers across the country. With this method, your premium is tied directly to your current age. As you get older, your premium automatically goes up.

The Appeal for 65-Year-Olds

When you are 65 and newly eligible for Medicare, attained-age policies often look incredibly attractive. Because you are at the youngest end of the Medicare spectrum, the insurer offers you their lowest possible rate. For someone on a fixed income who is just transitioning into retirement, this low entry-level price can be very tempting.

The Long-Term Reality

The catch with an attained-age policy is that your rate will increase as you age. Most companies adjust your premium automatically on your birthday or on the anniversary of the date your policy started.

For example, if you buy an attained-age policy at 65, you will pay the 65-year-old rate. When you turn 66, you will pay the 66-year-old rate. By the time you reach 80 or 85, these age-based increases can make the policy significantly more expensive than it was when you started. It is very common for an attained-age policy to eventually become the most expensive option over a 20-year retirement, even though it started out as the cheapest.

How Issue-Age Medigap Pricing Works

Issue-age pricing, sometimes called entry-age pricing, takes a different approach. With an issue-age policy, the insurance company bases your premium on your age at the exact moment you buy the policy.

Locking In Your Age Bracket

If you purchase an issue-age Medigap policy at age 65, you will always pay the rate designated for a 65-year-old. When you turn 75, you are still paying the rate that the company charges 65-year-olds, rather than the higher rate they charge new 75-year-old applicants.

Because the insurer knows they cannot raise your rates simply because you are having birthdays, they usually charge a higher starting premium than an attained-age policy. A 65-year-old buying an issue-age policy will likely pay more in their first few years than their neighbor who bought an attained-age policy.

The "Frozen Premium" Myth

One of the most common and dangerous misunderstandings in Medicare is the belief that an issue-age policy means your premium is frozen for life. This is absolutely false.

While an issue-age policy will not raise your rates due to your aging, your rates will still go up over time. Insurance companies adjust their rates for all policyholders to keep up with medical inflation and rising healthcare costs. So, while your rate won't jump up just because you blew out another candle on your birthday cake, it will increase when the cost of healthcare goes up.

How Community-Rated Medigap Pricing Works

Community-rated pricing, also known as "no-age-rated" pricing, is the simplest method to understand. Under this system, the insurance company charges the exact same monthly premium to everyone who has the same policy in a specific geographic area, regardless of how old they are.

How It Impacts Different Age Groups

If you buy a community-rated Plan G, you will pay the exact same monthly premium at age 65 as an 85-year-old neighbor who has the same plan.

For a 65-year-old, a community-rated plan can sometimes seem expensive because you are essentially subsidizing the older members of the risk pool. However, for someone who is 75 or 80 and shopping for a new policy, a community-rated plan can be a fantastic deal, because they are not being penalized for their advanced age.

Just like issue-age policies, community-rated policies do not experience age-based increases, but they will still go up over time due to inflation and rising medical costs.

Comparing Attained-Age vs Issue-Age Medigap Costs

To truly understand attained age vs issue age, you have to look at how the costs compare over a long period. When you compare Medicare Supplement rates, you are usually only seeing the price for your current age. Here is how the two methods generally behave over a 15-year period.

AgeAttained-Age Policy BehaviorIssue-Age Policy Behavior
Age 65Starts with the lowest possible premium.Starts with a moderate, slightly higher premium.
Age 70Premium has increased due to both aging (5 years) and inflation.Premium has increased due to inflation only.
Age 75Premium continues to climb sharply as the policyholder enters older age brackets.Premium rises steadily with inflation, but often becomes cheaper than the attained-age policy.
Age 80+Often becomes the most expensive option due to compounding age and inflation increases.Usually offers better long-term value, as the policyholder is still paying the "age 65" baseline rate.

The "breakeven point" is the age at which the total amount of money you have spent on an attained-age policy equals the total amount you would have spent on an issue-age policy. While it varies by company and location, many beneficiaries find that if they live well into their late seventies or eighties, an issue-age or community-rated policy ends up saving them money in the long run.

Why Medical Inflation Affects Every Medigap Policy

If you are frustrated by the idea that your premiums will go up no matter which rating method you choose, it helps to understand why this happens. Medigap policies are designed to pay the costs that Original Medicare does not. As the underlying costs of Medicare go up, the insurance companies have to pay out more money, which means they have to raise premiums to stay in business.

Rising Medicare Costs in 2026 and 2027

The Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS) adjusts Medicare costs almost every year. When these costs rise, your Medigap plan takes on a larger financial burden. Consider the official changes from 2026 to 2027:

  • Medicare Part B Deductible: Rose from $283 in 2026 to $292 in 2027.
  • Part A Inpatient Hospital Deductible: Rose from $1,736 in 2026 to $1,776 in 2027 per benefit period.
  • Part A Daily Coinsurance (Days 61-90): Rose from $434 per day in 2026 to $444 per day in 2027.
  • Skilled Nursing Facility Coinsurance (Days 21-100): Rose from $217 per day in 2026 to $222 per day in 2027.

Because your Medigap policy is on the hook for these larger deductibles and coinsurance amounts in 2027, the insurance company will pass those increased costs on to you in the form of a higher monthly premium. This is why you should always understand why your Medigap premium increased, rather than assuming your insurer is simply trying to price-gouge you.

How High-Deductible Plans Factor In

If you want to avoid steep premium hikes, some people look at High-Deductible Medigap Plans (like High-Deductible Plan G). These plans offer much lower monthly premiums, but you must meet a large deductible before the policy pays anything. This deductible was $2,950 in 2026 and rises to $3,050 in 2027. Because the insurance company has less risk (you are paying the first $3,050 out of pocket), the premiums are lower and the annual inflation hikes are usually smaller.

How Your State Regulates Medigap Rating Systems

While it is helpful to understand the differences between attained age vs issue age, you might not actually get to choose between them. Medigap is heavily regulated at the state level, and your state's department of insurance dictates which rating methods companies are allowed to use.

State-Specific Mandates

Several states have decided that attained-age pricing is unfair to older seniors and have banned it entirely. For example, states like New York, Connecticut, Massachusetts, and Maine mandate continuous open enrollment or require all plans to be community-rated. If you live in one of these states, every Medigap policy you look at will be community-rated by law.

Other states allow all three pricing methods, meaning you have to be careful when comparing quotes to ensure you are comparing apples to apples.

State Birthday Rules

Some states have implemented special "Birthday Rules." These rules allow you a brief window around your birthday each year to switch to a different Medigap policy with the same or lesser benefits without answering health questions. If you live in a state with a Medigap Birthday Rule, you might have more flexibility to start with a cheap attained-age policy at 65 and switch to a different company later, though you will still be subject to the new company's pricing structure for your older age.

Can You Switch Rating Methods Later?

A common strategy people attempt is to buy a cheap attained-age policy at age 65, and then try to switch to a more stable issue-age or community-rated policy at age 70 before the attained-age prices get too high. This strategy is incredibly risky due to medical underwriting.

The Medigap Open Enrollment Period

When you are 65 or older and first enroll in Medicare Part B, you are granted a one-time, 6-month Medigap Open Enrollment Period (OEP). During this six-month window, you have a federal guarantee to buy any Medigap policy sold in your state, regardless of your health. The insurance company cannot deny you, charge you more, or make you wait for coverage due to pre-existing conditions.

Medical Underwriting Outside the OEP

Once that 6-month window closes, your federal protection ends. Unlike Medicare Part B or Part D, Medigap does not have a standardized financial "late enrollment penalty." Instead, if you apply outside your OEP, insurers in most states can use medical underwriting.

This means they will ask you a series of health questions. If you have developed a chronic illness, survived cancer, or even just take certain medications, the Medigap plan can deny you for pre-existing conditions. Therefore, if you buy an attained-age policy at 65, you might be stuck with it for the rest of your life if your health declines, forcing you to pay those steep age-based increases in your eighties.

The Impact of MACRA on Closed Plans

When comparing long-term rate stability, it is also important to consider the history of the plan you are buying. Due to a law called MACRA, Medigap Plans C and F are no longer available to anyone who became eligible for Medicare on or after January 1, 2020. Plan G is now the most comprehensive plan available to new enrollees.

Because no new, healthy 65-year-olds can enter the risk pool for Plan F, the average age of people in Plan F is getting older, and they are requiring more medical care. This causes the premiums for Plan F to rise much faster than the premiums for Plan G, regardless of whether the policy is attained-age or issue-age. When choosing a plan for long-term stability, it is generally safer to choose a plan that is actively accepting new 65-year-olds.

Which Rating Method Offers Better Long-Term Stability?

There is no single "best" rating method for everyone, as the right choice depends on your budget, your state's laws, and how long you expect to keep the policy. However, you can use a simple checklist to help evaluate your options.

Decision Checklist for Medigap Pricing

  • Check your state laws: Find out if your state mandates community rating or allows attained-age policies.
  • Ask for the history: Ask the insurance company or your agent for the average historical rate increases for the policy over the last five years.
  • Calculate the breakeven point: Look at the premium difference between an attained-age and issue-age policy at age 65. Estimate how many years it will take for the attained-age policy to become more expensive.
  • Assess your health: If you have a family history of chronic illness, assume you will not be able to pass medical underwriting to switch plans later. Choose a pricing method you can afford at age 80.
  • Review your budget: If you absolutely need the lowest possible premium today to survive on a fixed income, an attained-age plan might be your only realistic option right now.

How to Find the Rating Method on Your Policy

Insurance companies are required to disclose their rating method, but it isn't always printed in large letters on the front of the brochure. Here is how you can find out how your current or prospective policy is priced:

If you are shopping for a new policy: The rating method will be listed in the "Outline of Coverage" document that the insurance company must provide before you apply. It is usually found in the first few pages under a section titled "Premium Information."

If you already have a policy: Check the original policy documents you received in the mail when you were approved. You can also look at your annual renewal notice, which will explain why your rate is changing. If all else fails, call the customer service number on the back of your Medigap card and ask a representative directly: "Is my policy attained-age, issue-age, or community-rated?"

How to Compare Medigap Rates in 30 Seconds

Understanding attained age vs issue age is crucial, but the first step is always seeing what plans actually cost in your specific ZIP code. At Genie Medicare, we believe in making this process completely transparent and hassle-free.

You can compare Medicare Supplement rates on our site in about 30 seconds. We show you the prices upfront, with no name, phone number, or email address required to see your options. If you find a plan you like, our friendly, licensed agents are available to provide free help, answer your questions about rating methods, and ensure you get your Medicare rate wish granted.

Let Genie grant your Medicare rate wish

Compare Medicare Supplement rates in about 30 seconds. No name, phone or email needed to see prices.

Frequently asked questions

Do issue-age Medigap premiums ever go up?

Yes. While issue-age policies do not increase your premium just because you get older, they still raise rates to keep up with medical inflation. As the underlying costs of Medicare deductibles and coinsurance rise, the insurance company will increase your premium to cover those higher expenses.

Can I switch from an attained-age to an issue-age policy later?

You can apply to switch at any time, but if you are outside your initial 6-month Medigap Open Enrollment Period, you will likely have to pass medical underwriting. If you have pre-existing health conditions, the new insurance company can deny your application or charge you a higher premium.

What is the best Medigap rating method?

There is no single best method. Attained-age plans are usually the cheapest when you are 65 but become very expensive as you age. Issue-age and community-rated plans cost more upfront but offer much better long-term price stability. The best choice depends on your budget and how long you plan to keep the policy.

Are High-Deductible Medigap plans rated the same way?

Yes, High-Deductible plans like Plan G can also be priced using attained-age, issue-age, or community-rated methods. However, because you are responsible for paying the deductible before the plan pays out, the starting premiums are much lower, and the annual rate increases tend to be smaller.

Does Plan G use issue age or attained age?

Plan G itself does not dictate the pricing method. The insurance company selling the Plan G decides whether to use attained-age, issue-age, or community-rated pricing, subject to your state's laws. You can find Plan G policies using all three methods depending on where you live.

Do community-rated plans cost more at age 65?

Often, yes. Because a community-rated plan charges the same premium to a 65-year-old as it does to an 85-year-old, the younger members are essentially subsidizing the older members. This makes the starting premium higher than an attained-age plan, but it protects you from massive age-based increases later in life.

Sources

  1. gohealth.com
  2. medicare.gov
  3. cms.gov
  4. cms.gov
  5. cms.gov
  6. kff.org
  7. medicare.gov
  8. medlifeguide.com
  9. kff.org

This article is for general information and isn't insurance, medical, legal or tax advice. Plan costs and benefits change every year and depend on where you live, your age and your health. Genie Medicare is not connected with or endorsed by the U.S. government or the federal Medicare program.

Older man and licensed agent looking at a laptop to check Medigap pre-existing conditions and compare plans. Medicare Supplement

Can Medigap Deny You for Pre-Existing Conditions?

Find out how pre-existing conditions affect your Medicare Supplement application and how to use your 6-month Open Enrollment window to guarantee your coverage.

15 min read

Older man pointing to a calendar date to track his Medicare Advantage trial right deadline Medicare Supplement

Medicare Advantage Trial Right: Rules to Switch Back

Did you try Medicare Advantage and realize it isn't for you? The federal trial right lets you switch back to Medigap without medical underwriting if you act in time.

10 min read